The following is a list of Casper Oilers who earned All-State Awards as of the 2009 Season.

2012 AA

1st Team – Cam Huber, Zack Mathson, Jon Robinson

2nd Team – Tanner Fischer, Dan Reese

2011 AA-A

1st Team – Alex Hill

2nd Team – DeLane Doyle, Jon Robinson

2010 AA-A

1st Team – Alex Hill, Lane Fischer

2nd Team – Eli Ford

2009 AA-A

1st Team – Zane Mathson

2nd Team – Lane Fischer, Eli Ford, Alex Hill